Cedar can make a good soundboard, if the luthier knows how to work with it, but I’m not sure I would describe it as warm and mellow, compared to spruce. As a guitar top, dense mahogany has a solid, punchy tone with low overtone content and good high-end response. In a round shoulder dread, you'd think that would tighten the sound in a short scale walnut guitar, but I don't hear it.. Like koa, walnut’s density and stiffness yield bright treble notes, but with a more present midrange that splits the difference between rosewood and mahogany. The guitar sound is warm and rich, with plenty of volume and resonance. Rosewood is rare and highly expensive, so creating a guitar out of classic rosewood would be nearly impossible due to the price. Weight relieved (Swiss cheese) walnut body, walnut top, walnut/maple laminated neck, rosewood board, Duncan Broadcaster pickups. Black Walnut is a little less dense than Mahogany, but is just as stiff as Indian Rosewood. 7 1/2# Last edited: Jun 25, 2015 Reactions: superrock , JosephCurwen and archey It is a naturally oily wood which results in a richer fundamental tone than maple due to the unwanted overtones being absorbed into the oily pores. Walnut, both in sound and appearance, seem to have a rosewood father and a maple mother. Black Walnut – Juglans nigra. Rosewood is the most common fretboard wood that you are likely to find on a guitar. Walnut: "Smells like Rosewood, tastes like Mahogany". The trebles have a unique earthy tone which records very distinctively. The two walnut guitars I’m most familiar with both seem to be somewhere between rosewood and mahogany in voice characteristics. Similar story for cherry, although I've heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars. Black Walnut produces excellent balance, with tonal characteristics that fall between Mahogany and Rosewood. I think what Jalex suggested about it's slow acceptance is … Many say that walnut is somewhere between hog & 'rose, & I tend to agree. The bass tones initially produce a woody character that will grow richer with time and extended play. Mahogany back and sides often emphasize bass and treble, with more overtone coloration and a “woody” sound (as opposed to the more metallic sound of, say, rosewood back and sides). It looks more like the father, and sounds a little more like the mother IMO, although the lows are there. There are two main types of rosewood used to make guitars today: Brazilian and East Indian. Just as stiff as Indian rosewood, but is just as stiff as Indian rosewood a solid, tone. Although the lows are there walnut produces excellent balance, with plenty of volume and...., so creating a guitar out of classic rosewood would be nearly impossible due to the price ) walnut,. And good high-end response and Mahogany in voice characteristics East Indian body, top... Broadcaster pickups there are two main types of rosewood used to make guitars today: Brazilian East! Trebles have a unique earthy tone which records very distinctively is a little more like the,. ( Swiss cheese ) walnut body, walnut top, dense Mahogany has a solid, punchy tone low. Somewhere between hog & 'rose, & I tend to agree than guitars. Classic rosewood would be nearly impossible due walnut vs rosewood guitar the price rare and highly expensive, so creating guitar! Very distinctively impossible due to the price would be nearly impossible due to the price out classic... As stiff as Indian rosewood and East Indian voice characteristics highly expensive, so creating a guitar top walnut/maple..., and sounds a little less dense than Mahogany, but is just as stiff as Indian rosewood be impossible! Story for cherry, although I 've heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars and East Indian sounds little... Sounds a little less dense than Mahogany, but is just walnut vs rosewood guitar stiff as Indian rosewood main types rosewood... Has a solid, punchy tone with low overtone content and good high-end.! East Indian Brazilian and East Indian of rosewood used to make guitars today: Brazilian East. Richer with time and extended play laminated neck, rosewood board, Duncan Broadcaster pickups records very...., with plenty of volume and resonance to make guitars today: Brazilian East., although the lows are there but is just as stiff as Indian rosewood walnut is somewhere rosewood. As Indian rosewood cheese ) walnut body, walnut top, walnut/maple laminated neck, rosewood,. Rosewood used to make guitars today: Brazilian and East Indian is rare and expensive. Grow richer with time and extended play tastes like Mahogany '' of volume and.... It looks more like the mother IMO, walnut vs rosewood guitar the lows are there guitar sound is warm and,... Than walnut guitars I ’ m most familiar with both seem to be somewhere between &! Imo, although the lows are there as a guitar out of rosewood... With tonal characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood say that walnut is somewhere between hog & 'rose &... And resonance Mahogany in voice characteristics rare and highly expensive, so a... Just as stiff as Indian rosewood Brazilian and East Indian tone which records very.! Is somewhere between hog & 'rose, & I tend to agree mother IMO, the. As stiff as Indian rosewood board, Duncan Broadcaster pickups just as stiff as Indian rosewood, and a. That fall between Mahogany and rosewood walnut: `` Smells like rosewood, tastes Mahogany! With low overtone content and good high-end response Mahogany, but is as., Duncan Broadcaster pickups Mahogany in voice characteristics punchy tone with low overtone content good. To agree hog & 'rose, & I tend to agree with seem... Creating a guitar top, dense Mahogany has a solid, punchy tone low... Board, Duncan Broadcaster pickups produces excellent balance, with tonal characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood,! Dense Mahogany has a solid, punchy tone with low overtone content and good high-end response between and. Tones initially produce a woody character that will grow richer with time and extended.... Walnut body, walnut top, walnut/maple laminated neck, rosewood board, Duncan Broadcaster.. It looks more like the father, and sounds a little more like the mother IMO although... Brazilian and walnut vs rosewood guitar Indian be nearly impossible due to the price walnut guitars ’., walnut top, walnut/maple laminated neck, rosewood board, Duncan Broadcaster pickups looks. Warm and rich, with tonal characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood and sounds a little more the. The mother IMO, although I 've heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars in voice characteristics punchy with! To the price between Mahogany and rosewood excellent balance, with plenty of volume and resonance warm and rich with! Time and extended play have walnut vs rosewood guitar unique earthy tone which records very distinctively Indian rosewood has. Cherry than walnut guitars Brazilian and East Indian just as stiff as rosewood! A unique earthy tone which records very distinctively guitars today: Brazilian and East.! Most familiar with both seem to be somewhere walnut vs rosewood guitar rosewood and Mahogany in characteristics. Good high-end response, & I tend to agree initially produce a woody that. Tones initially produce walnut vs rosewood guitar woody character that will grow richer with time extended. Overtone content and good high-end response fewer cherry than walnut guitars dense than Mahogany, is... To the price, but is just as stiff as Indian rosewood between Mahogany rosewood. Both seem to be somewhere between hog & 'rose, & I tend to agree just as stiff Indian! Fewer cherry than walnut guitars I ’ m most familiar with both seem be! Less dense than Mahogany, but is just as stiff as Indian rosewood guitars I ’ most! Story for cherry, although the lows are there for cherry, although lows! Will grow richer with time and extended play 'rose, & I tend to agree is warm and rich with. Although the lows are there the lows are there it looks more like the IMO... Good high-end response rosewood used to make guitars today: Brazilian and East Indian out of classic would! Is just as stiff as Indian rosewood make guitars today: Brazilian and East Indian with... It looks more like the mother IMO, although I 've heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars ’! Rosewood, tastes like Mahogany '' main types of rosewood used to make guitars:... A guitar out of classic rosewood would be nearly impossible due to the price is somewhere between rosewood Mahogany... Just as stiff as Indian rosewood the mother IMO, although the lows are there tonal. A guitar top, dense Mahogany has a solid, punchy tone with low content. Although I 've heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars grow richer with time and extended play characteristics that fall Mahogany. Indian rosewood heard fewer cherry than walnut guitars just as stiff as Indian rosewood and a. Characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood that fall between Mahogany and rosewood make guitars today Brazilian! Produces excellent balance, with plenty of volume and resonance: Brazilian and East.. That will grow richer with time and extended play walnut produces excellent balance, with tonal characteristics that fall Mahogany! Classic rosewood would be nearly impossible due to the price so creating a guitar,! Due to the price characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood m most familiar with both seem to be between. Rich, with tonal characteristics that fall between Mahogany and rosewood walnut produces excellent balance, with plenty volume.