The comments have since come back to bite her, not because many people have a kind word for imperialism these days but because she was comparing those colonial empires, which invaded and conquered territory by force of arms, to the “new empire” of Netflix. Manitoba‘s highest court said Jordan Peterson’s “dubious expert opinion” was “unreliable” and “unnecessarily complicated” a murder trial, June 25, 2018 No principle of aesthetics dictates that a work of art should be judged by whether it successfully indoctrinates members of a particular nation state in the belief that they are different from others. And yet it seems wrong to heap such particular scorn on Tait. Sign up to receive the daily top stories from the National Post, a division of Postmedia Network Inc. Get a better understanding and appreciation of Indigenous peoples, the role of the monarchy, as well as the languages, anthems and symbols that define Canada’s identity. Tweet. That should come as little surprise: 56% of Canadians have directly “experienced discrimination in Canada.”, The research also offers hints of alienation among older Canadians. Canadians overwhelmingly believe that diversity is a good in and of itself – in fact, it’s one of the top things that makes Canadians “proud” to be Canadian. The First Nations’ file has been another example of the Canadian identity crisis, one where the gap between the rhetoric and the reality is growing. Photo by Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press/File, tap here to see other videos from our team. birthplace? There was a time, that is, when cultural nationalism was absolutely accepted — when it was taken as a given among the educated classes that it was the responsibility of government to protect and defend Canadian culture, if necessary from Canadians themselves. The Canadian culture that nationalists wish to defend is inextricably shaped by our exposure to and absorption of American culture, “There was a time,” Catherine Tait was saying, “when cultural imperialism was absolutely accepted.”, The CBC president was musing, at an industry conference in Ottawa last week, about the heyday of the British and French Empires, when if “you were the viceroy of India you would feel that you were doing only good for the people of India.” Or, “if you were in French Africa, you would think ‘I’m educating them, I’m bringing their resources to the world, and I’m helping them.’ ”. “They (cybercriminals) threaten the privacy of Canadians through the theft of personal information, which facilitates additional criminal behaviour, including identity theft and financial fraud,” according to a report released Wednesday by the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) and its Canadian Centre for Cyber Security (CCCS). We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Invite students to sort the headlines into groups of factors, e.g., economic disparity, foreign threats, racial tensions, that impact Canadian national identity. Is it about art, or politics? And while the research shows the Canadians from all walks of life have regular interactions with people from different backgrounds, those interactions skewed lower than average among Canadians 55 years and older. 5 major threats to biodiversity, and how we can help curb them. Chris Selley: Netflix in Canada — an opportunity for the CBC, or imperialist menace? • That these differences are threatened. The (Canadian) comedian Martin Short once defined Canadians as “the people who watch a lot of American TV.” The Canadian culture that nationalists wish to defend is inextricably shaped by our exposure to and absorption of American culture — much of it created by expat Canadians. These threats include: untamed nature, as symbolized by the harshness of winter, the wilderness, or Indigenous peoples; the separatist movement of some Québécois nationalists; and the “balkanization” of the country due to a multicultural … 1583 , 1988 CanLII 131 This website uses cookies to personalize your content (including ads), and allows us to analyze our traffic. Netflix is one reason that Canadian television is increasingly enjoyed around the world. Those who identified “income inequality” as their top concern were more likely to have lower levels of education or be located in Atlantic Canada, although more than one-in-four Canadians identified inequality as an issue in Ontario, Quebec, British Columbia and Alberta too. Discrimination and hate crimes were identified as issues in the Prairies as well as Ontario and BC. The same defensive attitudes, what is more, have for decades formed the foundation of much government policy on culture, even if they are largely incomprehensible to a generation raised on Netflix and YouTube. • That these national cultures are meaningfully different. Is a Canadian setting enough? How do we even define a Canadian author: residence? We need your help to keepmaking an impact. no longer know what it means to be Canadian,” a sentiment Millennials strongly reject. Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Ask students to explain their groupings of the headlines. While the vast majority of Canadians 55 years and older say they fully embrace diversity, suspicion towards “immigrants” and “minority groups” is statistically higher in this age bracket – as well as concerns about addressing “immigrant integration.”. Please try again. Jordan Peterson Was an Expert Witness in a Murder Trial. We would just be that new version of ourselves. The second question is: how? Trudeau government told income inequality, discrimination and hate crimes are seen as biggest threats to Canada‘s social fabric. launching a multi-million dollar defamation lawsuit against Wilfrid Laurier University. Another so-called threat — rooted in the ‘The Great Replacement’ theory — is that immigration will wipe away the Canadian identity. The flinty insistence of cultural nationalists on the vast dissimilarity between what are arguably the two most similar nations on earth — outside the Quebec and Southern outliers, almost indistinguishable — is a particularly noteworthy example of Freud’s observation of “the narcissism of minor differences.”. All of these views link to the idea that Northrop Frye called a “garrison mentality.” Margaret Atwood identified it as the “survival” theme present in English Canadian literature. Share ” (27%) as the top area where the government needs to do more work to promote an inclusive society. Read more about cookies here. Even as a political project, mere difference seems an arid argument for national existence. A: Through the 1950s, ’60s, ’70s, and into the 1980s, there were three pillars of Canadian identity: peacekeeping, healthcare and the threat of Quebec separation.