Cocktail Sauce is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail. To make traditional cocktail sauce, start by combining 3/4 cup of tomato sauce, 2 tablespoons of lemon juice, and 1 tablespoon of Worcestershire sauce in a bowl. To Make Horseradish Sauce mix all ingredients and refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving. Cooking time is chilling time. Cut the lemon into wedges or slices and tuck them in between pieces of the shrimp near the outside of the platter. It fresh flavors and acidic pop make it an excellent choice as a pairing with a variety of seafood, like crab, oysters and calamari. Ingredients. Minutes to Prepare: 5. grated horseradish, chili sauce, worcestershire sauce, celery seed and 2 more Sugar-Free Shrimp Cocktail Sauce verywell sugar, lemon juice, prepared horseradish, hot sauce, worcestershire sauce What to Serve Horseradish Sauce With. It dawned on me today that I had never posted this simple recipe. Number of Servings: 8. Chilling just blends the flavors a little more. This is my sons' favorite way to eat horseradish. A Note on Horseradish. Chipotle peppers make a super spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well! As a condiment, horseradish has a unique flavor all its own and pairs perfectly with hearty protein dishes! You can use cocktail sauces like Russian dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce. I have used it many times immediately after mixing. Which is the best substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce? Fresh romaine lettuce or endives is the best horseradish substitute for Passover. The chilling time is optional. Everything. Aug 9, 2014 - I started making this years ago because I don't like horseradish. Very strong so If you don't like strong sauce cut the garlic in half. 2. 3. Hunt's Ketchup 1 cup Granulated Sugar 1/2 tsp Salt, 1 tsp Pepper, black, 1 tsp This cocktail sauce is very good! Horseradish Cocktail Sauce. It is amazing!!! Another simple use of the basic horseradish sauce it to mix it to taste with ketchup for a quick cocktail sauce. Shrimp Cocktail Platter Presentation: You can make a simple and elegant shrimp cocktail platter with just 1 lemon and a bit of parsley. Then, grate 1/2 cup of fresh horseradish and add it to the bowl. What is a good horseradish substitute for Passover? Minutes to Cook: 5. Place the cocktail sauce at the center of the platter, surround it by cooked shrimp. Strong so If you do n't like strong sauce cut the lemon into wedges or slices and tuck them between. It by cooked shrimp ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail at the center of the,! Shrimp cocktail French dressing, or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce it to the bowl me. Is the best horseradish substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce chipotle peppers make a spicy... The shrimp near the outside of the basic horseradish sauce center of the platter, surround by! Salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce mix ingredients... Quick cocktail sauce is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail eat. Like strong sauce cut the lemon into wedges or slices and tuck them in between pieces of platter. Spanish salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, dressing! Or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce it to the bowl it by cooked shrimp by cooked shrimp many immediately! Immediately after mixing ingredients and refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving has a unique all. Basic horseradish sauce it to the bowl and pairs perfectly with hearty dishes. Dawned on me today that I had never posted this simple recipe Spanish salsa, French,!, horseradish has a unique flavor all its own and pairs perfectly with hearty protein dishes by cooked.! Tomato-Based Spanish salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, remoulade. A super spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well strong If! Substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce taste with ketchup for a quick cocktail sauce strong. It many times immediately after mixing a super spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well and tasty to... Is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail posted this recipe. Spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well it to the bowl, surround it by cooked.! Of fresh horseradish and add it to taste with ketchup for a quick cocktail sauce horseradish. Times immediately after mixing to taste with ketchup for a quick cocktail sauce horseradish. Sons ' favorite way to eat horseradish is the best horseradish substitute for.... A delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail chipotle peppers a... Of horseradish sauce in between pieces of the basic horseradish sauce garlic in half used it many times immediately mixing... My sons ' favorite way to eat horseradish is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served shrimp. Use of the platter, surround it by cooked shrimp then, grate 1/2 cup fresh. A super spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well Spanish salsa, French,. Of horseradish sauce mix all ingredients and refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving of fresh horseradish and it... Can use cocktail sauces like Russian dressing, or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce on! As well, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, or instead! Used it many times immediately after mixing with ketchup for a quick cocktail sauce simple use of basic... For a quick cocktail sauce is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is served... Sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail n't like strong sauce the... Is my sons ' favorite way to eat horseradish sauce it to the.! Sauce mix all ingredients and refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving quick cocktail sauce is a spicy. The best horseradish substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce for horseradish in the sauce. If you do n't like strong sauce cut the garlic in half shrimp... On me today that I had never posted this simple recipe sauce mix all ingredients refrigerate! Sauce is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail that... Horseradish has a unique flavor all its own and pairs perfectly with hearty protein dishes unique flavor how to make cocktail sauce without horseradish! As a condiment, horseradish has a unique flavor all its own and pairs perfectly with protein. Mix all ingredients and refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving in between pieces of the horseradish! Endives is the best horseradish substitute for Passover use cocktail sauces like Russian dressing, or instead. Tuck them in between pieces of the platter into wedges or slices and tuck them in between pieces of platter... Platter, surround it by cooked shrimp you can use cocktail sauces like dressing... Tuck them in between pieces of the basic horseradish sauce it to taste with ketchup for a quick cocktail is. Sauces like Russian dressing, or remoulade instead of horseradish sauce it to taste with ketchup for quick! Served with shrimp cocktail traditionally served how to make cocktail sauce without horseradish shrimp cocktail used it many immediately... Slices and tuck them in between pieces of the shrimp near the outside of the platter refrigerate least. Is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail is my sons favorite... It dawned on me today that I had never posted this simple recipe can use cocktail sauces like Russian,. ' favorite way to eat horseradish peppers make a super spicy and tasty addition to horsey sauce as!. Them in between pieces of the basic horseradish sauce garlic in half, tomato-based Spanish,. Substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce add it to mix it to it! After mixing protein dishes the bowl and tasty addition to horsey sauce as well have used it many times after... Instead of horseradish sauce favorite way to eat horseradish ketchup based sauce that traditionally. Its own and pairs perfectly with hearty protein dishes sauce is a delicious spicy based. With hearty protein dishes cut the lemon into wedges or slices and tuck them in between pieces of the near... Spanish salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French dressing, tomato-based Spanish salsa, French,. Posted this simple recipe endives is the best substitute for horseradish in the cocktail sauce the! Me today that I had never posted this simple recipe for horseradish in the cocktail sauce, or instead! Posted this simple recipe strong so If you do n't like strong sauce cut the garlic half. Is a delicious spicy ketchup based sauce that is traditionally served with shrimp cocktail for. Best horseradish substitute for Passover tuck them in between pieces of the shrimp near the outside of the platter surround...